Last night review

[picklerunderwoodfan]

This is based on my opinion and remember.. I LOVE KELLIE PICKLER!

Lisa; Don't try and take on Kelly Clarkson's "Because of you".. it sounded like she was screaming it, i didn't like it. So far.. SO BAD! 4/10

Kellie; NOOOOOOOOO! Kellie.. I know you could do so much better ( but im still gonna vote for ya!) Next time do something more fun and shows your vocals. I love you! 6/10

Ace; Sick, thanks for ruining train.. I loved that song.. then you came on american idol... 4/10

Mandisa; you did okay.. my favorite of the night.. but still do better. 7/10

Chris; Don't start off like that ever again.. you needed to do "with arms wide open" or "higher" by creed. You would have rocked it! 6/10

Bucky; Can't stand you.. just get voted off already! 3/10

Paris; You had the best stage performing.. singing wasn't as good. 7/10

Elliot; I forgot about you.. that is not a good thing. Your version sucked. Sorry. 4/10

Katherine; *yawns* Come on Kat.. you could do so much better! 6/10

Taylor; Boring. 5/10

[kellie4idol5]

poor ratings.lol

best.kellie.elliott.paris.mandisa.kath

okay.ace.lisa.chris

worst.taylor.bucky

[Moodygal]

What was wrong with everybody?
It didn't sound very good, song choices were baaad! for everyone.
Kellie was very sweet, but the song?
I think Lisa is going home

[Ebony]

Not her fault......you can blame Miles for that. She IS a very pretty girl, if people could get past her size.

[Moodygal]

I think she is pretty, but she could lose a few pounds, it's not healthy.
She usually looks good and I like her, but the jeans didn't work, sorry.

[Lisa]

Originally Posted by picklerunderwoodfan

This is based on my opinion and remember.. I LOVE KELLIE PICKLER!

Lisa; Don't try and take on Kelly Clarkson's "Because of you".. it sounded like she was screaming it, i didn't like it. So far.. SO BAD! 4/10

Kellie; NOOOOOOOOO! Kellie.. I know you could do so much better ( but im still gonna vote for ya!) Next time do something more fun and shows your vocals. I love you! 6/10

Ace; Sick, thanks for ruining train.. I loved that song.. then you came on american idol... 4/10

Mandisa; you did okay.. my favorite of the night.. but still do better. 7/10

Chris; Don't start off like that ever again.. you needed to do "with arms wide open" or "higher" by creed. You would have rocked it! 6/10

Bucky; Can't stand you.. just get voted off already! 3/10

Paris; You had the best stage performing.. singing wasn't as good. 7/10

Elliot; I forgot about you.. that is not a good thing. Your version sucked. Sorry. 4/10

Katherine; *yawns* Come on Kat.. you could do so much better! 6/10

Taylor; Boring. 5/10

Woooooooo your ratings are a bit harsh sir. Somebody got a lil too close to Simon

[Hazelpaige]

nice review haha here's mine...the show sucked

[kellie15]

it was probly the worst show yet. the songs wernt good at all. kellie didnt do as well as she could but she was sick so it must been a bit harder for her. i thought kathrine did the best actually and lisa did the worst and i really dislike talyor hes anoying

[KellieThePick]

Originally Posted by picklerunderwoodfan

This is based on my opinion and remember.. I LOVE KELLIE PICKLER!

Lisa; Don't try and take on Kelly Clarkson's "Because of you".. it sounded like she was screaming it, i didn't like it. So far.. SO BAD! 4/10

Kellie; NOOOOOOOOO! Kellie.. I know you could do so much better ( but im still gonna vote for ya!) Next time do something more fun and shows your vocals. I love you! 6/10

Ace; Sick, thanks for ruining train.. I loved that song.. then you came on american idol... 4/10

Mandisa; you did okay.. my favorite of the night.. but still do better. 7/10

Chris; Don't start off like that ever again.. you needed to do "with arms wide open" or "higher" by creed. You would have rocked it! 6/10

Bucky; Can't stand you.. just get voted off already! 3/10

Paris; You had the best stage performing.. singing wasn't as good. 7/10

Elliot; I forgot about you.. that is not a good thing. Your version sucked. Sorry. 4/10

Katherine; *yawns* Come on Kat.. you could do so much better! 6/10

Taylor; Boring. 5/10

You have got to be kidding me with all what you just said!!!!

[Mona]

Lisa :: That Was Alright, I Loved The Song, But I Don't Think She Did Her Best.. 6/10

Kellie :: That Was Pretty Good, I Knew She Could Do A Lot Better, But She Still Did Good.. 7/10

Ace :: I Don't Know Why, But I Don't Like Him, I Don't Like His Voice Either, Especially To That Song.. 5/10

Mandisa :: For The First Time, I Didn't Think She Did So Good.. 6/10

Chris :: He Is A Fabulous Singer, And Also One Of My Favorites, But He Screamed Too Much, Just Repeating Words All The Time Gets Annoying, But I Still Love Him.. 7/10

Bucky :: I Thought He Did A Pretty Good Job, He's Also One Of My Favorites.. 7/10

Paris :: That Was Incredible, I'm Not Really A Fan Of Hers, But I Loved Her Performance.. 8/10

Elliot :: He's A Really Good Singer, But His Dancing Just Didn't Work With The Song, I Think I Was Comparing It To Bo's Version, Which Was Incredible, But I Still Liked It.. 7/10

Katharine :: She's My Favorite Idol Ever, And Always Will Be A Star, I Liked Her Performance, It Wasn't The Best, But I Still Loved It.. 8/10

Taylor :: Really Boring, I Never Liked Him.. 5/10

I Don't Really Agree With Anything That You Said, Jake..

[IdolFan2890]

Originally Posted by Hazelpaige

nice review haha here's mine...the show sucked

lol!!!!!!

[sawgod]

Hey be aware that right now, Kellie is sick with an ear infection, and sore throat. She is in a separate room from everyone. She sounded horrible in the interview before the song, and MSNBC confirmed it this morning. Gotta agree though, poor song. All of them, poor choices, just like last year for this theme.

[picklerunderwoodfan]

poor kellie!! hopefully she gets better!

[amanda_434]

This wasn't the best week......
Lisa 6/10
Kellie 7/10
Ace 5/10
Mandisa 9/10
Chris 9/10
Bucky 7/10
Paris 8/10
Elliot 6/10
Katherine 9/10
Taylor 5/10