Who will be the bottom two?

[Calculated]

I think Brenna and Stevie will be the bottom two. Although Brenna may be more popular than Melissa. Just based on performance, Brenna and Stephanie (aka Stevie) would be my bottom two.

Honorable mention for bottom:
Becky O'Donohue
Melissa McGhee
Kinnik Sky


Blew me away:
Mandisa
Katharine
Lisa

Did very well:
Kellie
Didn't like but understand how others would like:
Paris (bouncy)

[Kristi]

kinnik and brenna-- i didnt like them an i didnt like their singin.

[AshlaeSeacrest]

Brenna and Stevie based on perfromances.

Who blew me away:
Lisa
Melissa

Did very well:
Kellie
Mandisa

DID OK
Becky

[wallyworld]

I agree that Kelly was probably somewhere in the middle. Remember last year how Carrie started . You would have had to use a cattle prod to get her to move on stage. She had some good coaching and her stage presence improved a great deal.

[James]

You know just based on things I've seen posted around, I'm gonna say Heather and probably Kinnik or Heather and Becky go home. I think Stevie just made a very poor song choice decision and people are goign to feel sorry for her and give her one more chance.

[James]

Originally Posted by wallyworld

I agree that Kelly was probably somewhere in the middle. Remember last year how Carrie started . You would have had to use a cattle prod to get her to move on stage. She had some good coaching and her stage presence improved a great deal.

That's not true, Carrie's Could've Been performance was arguably her best performance of the whole season next to Alone. Her and Bo both flat knocked it out of the park that first week, setting themselves up as the ones to beat. It was week two that that things dwindled a little. But the first one was spot on.

Anyway, I'd rank Kellie 3rd or 4th either one based on performance. Lisa I thought did the best job, Katherine, ok I'll give her second and she's so trained she's alwasy going to be vocally perfect. Paris, well, she's really good but i dunno, I like Lisa a little better of the two. I think that's your top 4 girls though, the rest are comepting for the 4th and 5th spot.

[Calculated]

in response to James on Stevie and Heather:

I could see that happening, I can't remember heather's performance. I can remember Stevie's (aka Stephanie) so I wouldn't be surprised at that result. Either way, I think both are close to the end of the ride.

[wallyworld]

Voice wise it was great. She always showed great range. She did not gain stage presence until about the fifth week.

[James]

Defiantely... If Stevie makes it, she gets one chance to prove it or she's done. I hate it for Heather, because she's a NC girl too, but there's no wow factor there, nothing makes me want to pay attention to her. I think she made the worst song choice of any of them and she didn't deliver.

[KellieShellieGirl]

bottom 2 should be Stevie and Brenna

[Lisa]

I think Stevie deserves another chance. Obviously is u note my blend. She just had a rough night.

I hope Becky and Brenna leave. But I also didn't care much for Heather or kinnik's performances.

Melissa did awesome in my opinion and I think it sucks that this was her first performace america got to see. Cause nobody knew her really.

Kellie, Lisa, Mandisa and Paris also did awesome!

[Marissa]

Originally Posted by KellieShellieGirl

bottom 2 should be Stevie and Brenna

Agree!!

[i luv kellie]

I think Brenna will be leaving.....I hope!!! And sadly I think Stevie will be too.

[kellie4idol5]

im so scared! i dont want anyone to go home!! im gonna cry!!

[Calculated]

Votes so far:

Brenna 7
Stevie 5
Kinnik 2
Heather 1
Becky 1

Of note, stevie gets sympathy even voted for the bottom...Maybe she'll get a reprieve...looks like adios to Brenna.