*David Cook Voting Thread* - Page 3

AshlaeSeacrest · 05-22-2008, 07:20 AM

Congrats to my Word Nerd! I'm so happy for him. I would have hated to see him take 2nd place because he deserved to win. Plus it was my birthday on Tuesday(Thanks to the kelliebeans that voted for Cookie) so this was kinda like one of my many b-day gifts. Happy to see Kristy and Brooke last night. It's too bad the top 5 only got their duets because I wish Kristy could have got one too.

KellieandCarrieFan · 05-22-2008, 02:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by AshlaeSeacrest

Congrats to my Word Nerd! I'm so happy for him. I would have hated to see him take 2nd place because he deserved to win. Plus it was my birthday on Tuesday(Thanks to the kelliebeans that voted for Cookie) so this was kinda like one of my many b-day gifts. Happy to see Kristy and Brooke last night. It's too bad the top 5 only got their duets because I wish Kristy could have got one too.

Happy B-Day. And Yeah I Wish Kristy Could Have Had One. That's Why I Wanted Her To Make The Top 5. lol. They Did Seem To Focus More On Her In The Group Performances Though. At Least From What I Could See. lol. I LOVED Brooke's Duet. That Was Really Good. And Cook Was Good Too. The Rest Of The Top 5 I Could Take Or Leave. lol. What They SHOULD Have Done IMO Is Had The Top 10 Do Duets And Cut Out All That Pointless Stuff They Put In To Pass Time. But That's Me. LOl. Brooke and Kristy Looked Really Beautiful. Great To See Them Back And Having a Great Time. Congradulations Cookie.

KellieandCarrieFan · 05-22-2008, 02:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by lionel2341

I was Happy to see Brooke get a solo, but I also wanted to see Kristy come out and sing.

I think the "Your my Brother" guy was stupid and used up too much air time. I would have loved to see Jason Aldean do a duet with Kristy, that would have been great. Carrie as usual was awesome, can't wait to see her again in August.

Ernie

PS It was nice to see Haley after the show, she looked Stunning.

Thats what I was thinking. I would have loved to see Kristy get a duet. She earned it IMO and if they gave Michael and Carly one they should have given her one even if it was just with another contestant. lol. After all she placed higher then Michael and I just like to see things done fairly. lol. Another thing I would have loved is to see Kristy and Martina sing a duet. Oh that would have been GREAT!! Anything really. I just wish I could have seen her more but it was still great to see her. And I agree that Brooke did AWESOME!! I didn't see Haley. Too bad. I LOVE her. lol. Carrie and Jordin also did really well.

fanofkellie · 05-22-2008, 05:33 PM

I tried voting for David Cook Tuesday night but could never get through. As it turns out my votes weren't needed. I wasn't expecting the margin of victory to be as large as it was. I actually gave a shout-out of joy when he was announced the winner. I loved the show. I think it was the best finale ever. I loved the Carly and Michael duet. They were terrific. I was a little surprised they didn't talk a little bit to Carrie after her performance.

AshlaeSeacrest · 05-23-2008, 06:50 AM

You know what I think Idol gave Michael and Carly a duet because they were the two contestants many people thought that they were ''robbed'' and ''left before their time''. I'm also getting this feeling both Michael and Carly will be getting sign to Idol's Sony BMG along with Cook and Archuleta. There have been rumors going on that Idol will be signing contestants from this season that weren't in the final 2 and I think that's Carly and Michael.

lionel2341 · 05-23-2008, 09:48 AM

I Know that Brooke and Kristy are in talks already

Can't tell ya just yet

remember early on when I said that Nashville was watching.

Ernie

KellieandCarrieFan · 05-23-2008, 09:53 AM

I remember seeing an interview with Kristy and Michael where they both said they ahd some interest. So it dosn't surprise me. And I'm glad about Brooke too. Not that it surprises me or anything. lol.

AshlaeSeacrest · 05-23-2008, 11:48 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by lionel2341

I Know that Brooke and Kristy are in talks already

Can't tell ya just yet

remember early on when I said that Nashville was watching.

Ernie

Well that doesn't surprise me at all Ernie. I can see both Kristy and Brooke (especially Kristy) going the country route. Too bad the themes on the show weren't current because I always thought Brooke would do amazing on ''Love Song'' or Jewel song from the 90s. I know Brooke's style of music with pop/singer-songwriter has become very popular in today's music but if she wants to do country, I think going down the Taylor Swift route is a good idea for her too. I'll be buying both of their albums when they get released.

KellieandCarrieFan · 05-23-2008, 12:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by AshlaeSeacrest

Well that doesn't surprise me at all Ernie. I can see both Kristy and Brooke (especially Kristy) going the country route. Too bad the themes on the show weren't current because I always thought Brooke would do amazing on ''Love Song'' or Jewel song from the 90s. I know Brooke's style of music with pop/singer-songwriter has become very popular in today's music but if she wants to do country, I think going down the Taylor Swift route is a good idea for her too. I'll be buying both of their albums when they get released.

Oh Me Too. They Both Have The Star Quality IMO. One Of The Reasons I Always Wanted To Hear A Duet With Them(And We Got A Mini One, Yeah!! LOL) Is because I Think Their Style Of Music Is So Similar. I Can See Them BOTH Doing Well With Whatever Album They Put Out As They've BOTH Got The Power To Go Far. And I'm Not Surprised At All That People Are Paying Attention. IMO, They Both Left Too Soon. LOL

kelliedawnpicklerfan · 05-23-2008, 01:59 PM

Like my new Cookie blend?