David, David or Syesha? Who Will Win? - Page 2

KellieandCarrieFan · 05-09-2008, 07:28 PM

Its like I've said before... I really don't care anymore. lol. My top 4 were eliminated back to back since top 8. So I really have no stake in it anymore. lol. But I've been saying since the beginning of this season that they want a rocker and with Michael gon that leaves David Cook. And he HAS Been at the top of the votes for a long time now. I'd be very surprised if anyone else won. lol. I'm starting to think it may be a Syesha/David Cook Finale with David A Going home next week. Say what you want but with the exception of two seasons it has ALWAYS been a Boy/Girl Finale. lol. And I have a feeling some of Brooke's votes may go to Syesha. Jason's Votes will probably go to Cook. And I know a few of Kristy's fans have started voting for Syesha because she's taken over the role of the underdog. lol. I wouldn't be surprised if it was a David/David fonale simply because that's what they've been pushing for so long but I'm also starting to think it may just be Syesha/Cook. lol.

AshlaeSeacrest · 05-09-2008, 07:52 PM

I've heard some things about David A's father and what he did this week about the lyrics to David's Stand By Me and what he did to the other contestants (I've heard about him harassing some of the contestants). The AI lawyers are after him now. That might be the reason why Cook and Jason didn't seem happy and imo off their game last week. If they can't handle his dad, I don't see how Archie can win. It might just be a Syesha/Cook finale if AI realizes they don't want to deal with Archie's dad anymore.

KellieandCarrieFan · 05-09-2008, 08:00 PM

Wow, I hadn't heard all of that about his dad. i knew he was a problem but I had no idea that he was harassing other contestants. Your right then. AI may just decide they don't want to handle his dad. bad press is bad press. lol.

AshlaeSeacrest · 05-09-2008, 08:17 PM

I feel sorry for Archie. If his dad really is causing problems for him and the other contestants, they could vote him off Wednesday and then wait till he's 18 in December to sign him to their record label. He will officially be an adult and they won't have to worry about dealing with his dad anymore. I do believe the rumors about his dad and there's more to the story than it seems. He is a stage dad and I hope Archie can ''breakaway''. I don't want him to turn into another Lindsay Lohan or Britney Spears if he lets his dad control his life after he's 18 because I have a feeling he'll end up just like other stage parent's kids sadly.

Pickled Pink · 05-09-2008, 08:38 PM

I've heard rumors about David A.'s dad too...that he's a stage dad and has a bad temper and is very demanding and controlling. But David A. will soon be able to control his own career. And I am not sure if AI can pull him or not if he brings in the most votes even if they are wary about dealing with his dad.

And after all, they have their lawyers too I'm sure.

AshlaeSeacrest · 05-09-2008, 08:41 PM

The thing is AI is VERY mad at Archie's dad for making Archie sing ''Beautiful Girls'' in the middle of Stand By Me after the producers told his dad they couldn't allow Archie to sing that. That's a lyric to 2007's Sean Kingston song and that cost them millions of dollars because the song is VERY recent and the song wasn't cleared for contestants to sing. They can send any contestant home anytime they want to even if they had the most votes because they are allowed to throw out votes. It's called a ''clause'' and it's in the contract or something. AI has claused a lot of contestants in the past.

pick_pickler23 · 05-09-2008, 08:46 PM

I want David Cook to win out of those 3 but I think Archuleta will win. When the new American Idol attraction opens, the winner will be performing on the opening day. Archuleta is the perfect Disney performer...partly why I think he will win.

fanofkellie · 05-09-2008, 09:55 PM

Where is the information coming from that Archuleta's dad is harassing the other contestants, and also about the AI lawyers getting involved?

pick_pickler23 · 05-10-2008, 06:06 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by fanofkellie

Where is the information coming from that Archuleta's dad is harassing the other contestants, and also about the AI lawyers getting involved?

I've been seeing negative things about David's dad in different articles throughout the season. I saw the one that everyone is talking about but I forget where it's from.

AshlaeSeacrest · 05-10-2008, 06:40 AM

TMZ is reporting it. Yeah that TMZ. But let me just say that Nigel is VERY connected to TMZ and I believe AI linked the story to them. Lately TMZ has been VERY right everytime they are reporting something about AI now. I have heard from different sources not just TMZ that Jeff Archuleta is a stage dad. He has been treating his son, production staff and harassing the contestants ever since the top 12 but now AI took action because what Jeff did it got them money. This explains why performances were VERY sucky on Tuesday night. This explains why Brooke was being very overly emotional and Jason's ''I don't care about this anymore'' attitute. I wouldn't want to be there if his dad was causing trouble for everyone. I would be scared to be around him because he's totured other contestants when Archie was on Star Search. That's why I was VERY scared when Cook has to go to the hospital for his BP weeks ago. I thought he had slip something in his drink or food because Jeff has that before. It's also explains why Cook seemed off this week and he said that ''his head wasn't in the right place''. Randy telling him to ''shake it off'' on Tuesday. Even Jason said in a recent interview that a lot of things were happening on Tuesday morning were WRONG. Along side not being mature enough, this is also a reason why I wished Archie had waited a couple of years before he auditioned. They may not clause Archie to get him voted off Wednesday but I know one thing: He's not going to win now. His dad has caused so much trouble that's he's now ruined his son's chances of winning. I believe now more than ever regardless if Archie or Syesha leave Wednesday, David Cook will win American Idol no matter who's in the final 2 with him.

kelliedawnpicklerfan · 05-10-2008, 08:07 AM

TMZ is my homepage and I also saw about Archie's Dad being banned from the AI set and if what TMZ says is true I don't think he's a very good Dad!

Pickled Pink · 05-10-2008, 08:33 AM

That's too bad! Archie seems like such a sweet kid! It kind of reminds me of how Michael Jackson was raised. His father acted like that too.