Top 4 Show Season 7

[KellieandCarrieFan]

I like David A's voice but I just feel like he doesn't have the pop star appeal the way Kelly Clarkson did and may end up like Taylor Hicks did once Idol is over. lol. I have nothing against him, I just don't think he'll do as well as most people do beacuse he doesn't sing what's current and quite frankly he bores me almost as much as Jason and Syesha. lol. I like his voice but he needs to do something different because IMO, something is missing from his performances. lol.

As for who I think will be the top 5 of this season... its Kristy, Brooke, Carly, Michael and David Cook who I think will end up with the most success. And they would have been MY top 5 this season as well. Syesha won't be a mega star or anything but I think she'll have GREAT success in Broadway. The rest of them will fade into the backgroud IMO.

[KellieandCarrieFan]

Originally Posted by Kira

I guess everyone has their preferences; that's what makes so much diversity and choice in the world. I dont think that David Cook is all that great; he has a powerful voice but it seems same old same old each week. However, he could end up like Daughtry, who knows? In this business, surprises happen; totally unpredictable.

I would have prefered Michael over David Cook if they wanted the rocker this year but that's not what we got and out of the remaining four I thonk he's the one who stands the biggest chance of winning because he's the most consistent. I'm not that big on ANY of the remaining four though.

[KellieandCarrieFan]

Originally Posted by lionel2341

What a Boring show, Can someone in their right mind tell me how in the H*** Jason is still on the show and Talent like Brooke, Kristy, Carly and Michael are not????? This kid is way over his head. Voting has to change on this show. Text msg'ing should be limited to internet only where IP's can be verified like they do for DWTS and limited calls from a telephone number. This way we can do away with Dial Idol and Vote for the worst Ding Dongs. Something has to change, we're getting too many bad singers into the top.

I know everyone is GOO GOO over Archie, but I'm still going on record that He and Jason will fade into the sunset once the tour is over. David C. will do well and Syesha goes to broadway and will not become a mega star.

I believe Brooke, Kristy, Carly and Michael will come out of AI 7 as the "Real" winners and have very successful careers. None of the present Top 4 has received any phone calls from industry named artists. Kristy and Brooke are the talk of Nashville with many of my former and present Colleagues. When you have newcomers and veterans like Jason Aldean and Carly Simon call you, you know your being looked at.

Ernie

I agree. I kept asking myself how these four made it to the top over Michael, Kristy, Brooke and Carly, who ALL would ahve done SO much better IMO. They were my top 4 this saeson and NOT what we have on our screens right now. How Jason lasted THIS long is beyond me and I just hope he FINALLY goes home tonight. lol. I agree that Kristy, Brooke, Carly and Michael will be the real success stories this year. Watching Carly and Michael sing on Ellen yesterday aws GREAT!! Oh how different this show would have been if MY top four would have made it. lol

[No_Left_Turn]

it was like Castro wasn't even trying. What gives?

Anybody see Michael Johns and Carly Smithson on the Ellen DeGeneres show yesterday, they did really well as a duet.

[KellieandCarrieFan]

Originally Posted by No_Left_Turn

it was like Castro wasn't even trying. What gives?

Anybody see Michael Johns and Carly Smithson on the Ellen DeGeneres show yesterday, they did really well as a duet.

Yeah that's what I was talking about in my pervious post. lol. I liked them singing together. wonder if they'll be paired up on the tour. Castro wasn't trying at all and was HORRIBLE!! lol.

[Kira]

yes, Jason was horrible: even that's an understatement. We will all know if this is strictly a popularity contest if he does not go home tonight.

[AshlaeSeacrest]

As far as post AI careers, I see David Cook and Brooke the most successful. Kristy too but I'm afraid people will label her as another blonde country singer so she may have to do something that makes her stand out from the rest. Syesha will be OK with boardway and maybe some TV/movie acting as well I see Michael and Carly having a career, don't know how successful they will be since they had 2nd or 3rd chances with major record label deals and they failed. What makes you think they are gonna make it big now especially when being on AI doesn't mean you'll be successful? I see them having decent careers though, just not overly successful. I don't care what anybody says but David Archuleta is the next Taylor Hicks especially if he wins. Sorry I don't get the appeal and he isn't even as hip or as cool as Miley Cyrus/Jonas Brothers.

Now onto last night as I said in the other thread my boy Cook was different last night not his usual self. He did OK though. I have to say that I feel bad for Jason. The judges and the producers have VERY down right hateful mean it's disgusting. I find it very disrespectful how they treat him. I hope he does go home so he doesn't have to deal with their abuse anymore. I'm no fan at all and I've disliked her for the entire season but I thought Syesha was the best. Even though she won't win, she's improving much like Kristy did this season. I wouldn't mind seening a Syesha VS. Cook in the finals. A Rocker VS A Diva would be kinda fun.

[kelliesmyidol06]

David A was amazing!! and ya... jason NEEDS to go!!

[fanofkellie]

I also think a David Cook and Syesha finale would be interesting, but it most likely will be the two Davids.

[fanofkellie]

Although I think both Kristy and Brooke have a chance at success in Nashville, my final four would have consisted of David Cook, Carly, Michael, and Syesha.