Top 5 Show Season 7

Kira · 04-29-2008, 07:11 PM

Well, guys, I dont think I will be too popular with the Jason Castro lovers, but I thought he was the weakest one tonight. Having said that, he does have quite an appeal with the young gals, so I would not be surprised at all if he stays. For me, David Archeleta was the best tonight and I dont agree with Simon that his first performance was amateurish at all. His voice is the bomb! And he showed a different side tonight completely. I thought Brooke and Syesha did great especially Brooke on her second song and Syesha on both. David Cook is the resident rocker and he was quite good but not as amazing as usual IMO. Really dont know who will go home tomorrow night, but if it is based on performance, IMO it would be Jason. We'll see, we've been shocked bfore big time! Let me know what you all think.

KellieandCarrieFan · 04-29-2008, 07:28 PM

Hasn't Aired Here Yet But I Would Be Happy If Jason Went. I've Thought he Stayed Way Past His Time Anyways. Sorry Jason Lovers, I Just Haven't Been That Impressed By Him Lately. LOL. I Just Hope Brooke Stays. She's The Only One Left I Really Care About. LOL. I'll Admit That The Two David's Have A Good Voice, They're Just Not My Cup Of Tea. LOL. At This Point Though, NOTHING Would Surprise Me, Though I Would Guess It Would Be Either Jason Or Syesha Based On Fanbase. I Know The Other Three Have Larger Ones And We All Know At This Point Its A Poularity Contest. LOL

rwealone · 04-29-2008, 08:17 PM

I agree with both of you; Castro should go. He's way overdue for going home.

I want to vote for the cutie-pie violinist in the orchestra. She's a hottie!!

AshlaeSeacrest · 04-29-2008, 09:59 PM

OK I'm going to make this quick because tonight was a HOT mess. There's nothing left to say because THAT was terrible.

Who I want to go home: David A (I thought his performances were terrible and the judges still fall all over him especially Randy.)

Who will go home: Brooke OR Jason

KellieandCarrieFan · 04-29-2008, 10:46 PM

Ok Now That I've Actually Watched It I Have To Say That Jason Was By Far The Worst. Not Only Were His Vocals Not That Good But He Flat Out Put Me To Sleep. LOL. I Thought Brooke Was GREAT With Her Second Song And Her First One Wasn't As Bad As They Said It Was. LOL. I Am SO Pver David A. I Liked Him In The Beginning But I'm Getting Burned Out On Him. He's Been Just Ok For The Last Few Weeks. David Cook Needs To Brush His Hair. I swear He Looked Like He Just Rolled Out Of Bed And That Was distracting To Me. lol. He Was Just Ok, But The Second Song Was Better Then The First. Syesha, Never Been A Fan But She Was Decent Tonight. The First Song Bored Me Though. LOL. PLEASE Let Brooke Be Safe.

Astropickledeggs · 04-30-2008, 01:28 AM

The wrong contestant has gone home 3 weeks in a row, but then of course Jason could only go home once. If there is any justice, he will finally get the honors to hit the road this week because he was by far outdone by everyone Tuesday night, even on an overall so-so night.

My favorite remaining contest (after Kristy Lee) is Brooke and I thought she did a great job with "I am I said". Not bad at all with "I'm a Believer". I wanted to knock Simon along side the head after he called it a 'nightmare'.

Might just be that Simon is looking for attention.

Both David's and Syesha did better the second time around after rather uninspiring performances to start things off, especially Syesha.

I'd predict Jason going home, but lately predicting this show has been about as dependable as Paula having the use of a brain.

(sorry, don't mean to offend anyone who may like Jason)

KellieandCarrieFan · 04-30-2008, 02:29 AM

I Don't Really Care Who Goes Home As Long As Its Not Brooke. LOL> Kristy Was My Favoriate And Then Brooke. Well Actually I Had Three Favoriates All Season... Kristy, Michael and Brooke. Only One Of them Made It So She's Getting My Full Support. I Think The Last Three Weeks Have Been Wrong And Trying To Predict Who Goes Home Has Gotten Even Harder. Jason SHOULD Get The Boot, But Whether Or Not He does Remains To Be Seen. This Season Is So Messed Up, Its Ridiculous. LOL> I Really LOVED Brooke's Performance Though So I Hope She's Safe. But Then Again Three weeks In A Row Someone Has Gone Home After A Good Performance So Who Knows. lol.

wowMEwow · 04-30-2008, 04:59 AM

I love Archie!!! Archie Archie!! Anyways, why were they so rushing this time? I remember the other years they had the same night with a full 2 hours, and..everybody change clothe lol

AshlaeSeacrest · 04-30-2008, 05:29 AM

After that messup with Paula talking about Jason's 2nd performance of the night before he even sang, I don't think they will be able to send him home. It's obvious that what I've been saying is true all along. The judges get scripts from the producers every week. That's why I say sadly Brooke may go home or in a shocking boot David A. I'm putting my money on Brooke though :sad face:

lionel2341 · 04-30-2008, 05:44 AM

WOW!! talk about a disaster, this has got to be the worst show ever. I actually liked Brooke and Syesha better then the rest. Jason was the real disaster, and David A. put me to sleep, boy are they pimping him, it's a joke of a show. I guess you can tell I'm a little bitter. In all fairness to Brooke, Simon is a real jerk this season. She IS the only one who's record I would buy.

I'm predicting right now that if David A. wins this competition, he will be another Taylor Hicks. There are only 3 left who have a hell's chance in making it in the real world outside of AI, and that's Brooke, David C. and Syesha on Broadway. That's it.

All the other Real talent are gone.

Coming from the Recording industry, I have a pretty good Idea what will sell. I think
Kristy Lee Cook, Brooke White, Carly Smithson, will be huge. David Cook will do great. And if someone is smart enough to pick up Alaina Whitaker and be a mentor, she will also be great. Syesha will do well on Broadway, but not as a general recording artist, she's too generic. David A, and Jason, I'm sorry to say will fade into the sunset. How can anybody say that Jason was better then Brooke last night?? Even though Simon didn't like her first song, she had fun with it. Her second song was a perfect fit for her. She is a class act.

Ernie

kelliedawnpicklerfan · 04-30-2008, 05:52 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by AshlaeSeacrest

After that messup with Paula talking about Jason's 2nd performance of the night before he even sang, I don't think they will be able to send him home. It's obvious that what I've been saying is true all along. The judges get scripts from the producers every week. That's why I say sadly Brooke may go home or in a shocking boot David A. I'm putting my money on Brooke though :sad face:

^ Ashlae you are RIGHT the show is VERY scripted! Unfortunatly! AND NO BROOKE IS SAFE CUZ I VOTED 4 HER ALL NIGHT LONG!!

Dial Idol says this:DialIdol.com - Measuring the busy signal. Syesha DID NOT get the highest,Jason is going home, My Brooke is SAFE and DAvid cook was SEXY last night!

AshlaeSeacrest · 04-30-2008, 06:21 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by lionel2341

WOW!! talk about a disaster, this has got to be the worst show ever. I actually liked Brooke and Syesha better then the rest. Jason was the real disaster, and David A. put me to sleep, boy are they pimping him, it's a joke of a show. I guess you can tell I'm a little bitter. In all fairness to Brooke, Simon is a real jerk this season. She IS the only one who's record I would buy.

I'm predicting right now that if David A. wins this competition, he will be another Taylor Hicks. There are only 3 left who have a hell's chance in making it in the real world outside of AI, and that's Brooke, David C. and Syesha on Broadway. That's it.

All the other Real talent are gone.

Coming from the Recording industry, I have a pretty good Idea what will sell. I think
Kristy Lee Cook, Brooke White, Carly Smithson, will be huge. David Cook will do great. And if someone is smart enough to pick up Alaina Whitaker and be a mentor, she will also be great. Syesha will do well on Broadway, but not as a general recording artist, she's too generic. David A, and Jason, I'm sorry to say will fade into the sunset. How can anybody say that Jason was better then Brooke last night?? Even though Simon didn't like her first song, she had fun with it. Her second song was a perfect fit for her. She is a class act.

Ernie

I can agree with you. Out of everyone left I do see Brooke, David C. and Syesha on boardway are the only people who can make it in the real world. I know people think David A can appeal to the teen market but he's NO Miley Cyrus or Jonas Brothers, heck he's not even Zac Efron or anybody else in High School Musical. He just doesn't have that certain ''it'' factor to make it in the teen scene.

And Sorry Emily I hate to say it but I really do think Brooke is leaving us tonight. I hope I'm wrong though. I'm wanting David A to go personally. Like Ernie, he put me to sleep too. He was awful and the judges keep pimping him. At least they criticize Jason and the others when they are bad. They don't even do that with Archuleta.