Top 6 Results

nobelson · 04-23-2008, 08:03 PM

guys i need some positivity
i've never cried this hard
its close to my birthday and carly was doing so good

its ALWAYS like this.
first kellie now carly. top 6.

i don't even have anyone to hug right now. i am so. so. so sad.

i just broke my window .

rwealone · 04-23-2008, 08:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by nobelson

guys i need some positivity
i've never cried this hard
its close to my birthday and carly was doing so good

its ALWAYS like this.
first kellie now carly. top 6.

i don't even have anyone to hug right now. i am so. so. so sad.

i just broke my window .

Yeah, tonight's results really bite!!

I hope you didn't cut yourself.

nobelson · 04-23-2008, 08:18 PM

No, I'm okay.

I saw in Carly what I saw in Kellie. Someone that had dreams so big that I would do the impossible to help them achieve that.

I know many of you didn't like Carly, but I loved her.

Kellie was sixth, Carly was sixth.

I just hope she can be as succesful as Kellie has been. Even though it's a completely different industry.

north_clt · 04-23-2008, 08:27 PM

This is the third week in a row that someone has been sent home after a great performance.

I feel your pain.

I was not a Carly fan, but the girl has real talent.

Young_br · 04-23-2008, 09:01 PM

hey buddy!
man i was so scared to see the show that i prefered watch the Girlicious finale than American Idol so i this time i wasn't on msn to talk to you, i hope you are okay, i know how are you feeling, you are probaly saying "American Idol sux" and those stuffs... i cried when Kellie and Alaina left, let's just hope that she will have a succefful career like Kellie... since season 2 all the 6th places got a record deal so don't stop believing.

fanofkellie · 04-23-2008, 10:34 PM

I am very surprised Carly was eliminated. I thought she, at least, should have finished in the final three, if not be in the finale with David Cook.

north_clt · 04-24-2008, 05:30 AM

Carly was at least talented, interesting and worth watching for the full two minutes (or whatever) she was singing.

I had a hard time making myself watch the full performances this week, in some cases.

Without naming names, it was too much of the same old, same old in one case, and just too weird to watch in another.

I am still hoping one of the girls will join David Cook in the finale.

lionel2341 · 04-24-2008, 05:34 AM

Even though I was not a fan of Carly's, she is very talented. However, I believe her rendition of "Jesus Christ Superstar" did her in. It turned off a lot of people.

Ernie

Pickled Pink · 04-24-2008, 07:19 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by lionel2341

Even though I was not a fan of Carly's, she is very talented. However, I believe her rendition of "Jesus Christ Superstar" did her in. It turned off a lot of people.

Ernie

Not meaning to offend anybody, but I kind of agree with Ernie. The chorus on Jesus Christ Superstar just didn't quite come across. It's supposed to carry the whole song.

But wishing Carly all the best because she is a talented girl and she deserves a shot at it.

kelliedawnpicklerfan · 04-24-2008, 07:21 AM

I wihs ms. Carly the best! America got it wrong!

robert1848 · 04-24-2008, 08:30 AM

It's been many years since I saw the play, but I think I remember the song "Jesus Christ, Superstar" being in part (the chorus) an ensemble number. There is certainly a solo part in it, but I remember the entire cast coming in on the chorus.

The song is sung by Judas, questioning whether Jesus is really who is says is is. Not a feel good song or happy song in my opinion. I always thought the "superstar" monikor in the song a bit sarcastic, coming from Judas. I'm not sure Carly got the song.

I just don't think this song is a good choice for a solo performance number. I agree with Ernie. Once again, bad song choice is probably the determining factor. Certainly not her talent.

I am surprised that no one did "I Don't Know How To Love Him" from Jesus Christ, Superstar, one of the most beautiful songs ALW has written.

Kira · 04-24-2008, 10:20 AM

I think that Christy or even Brooke could have sang that song Robert. Kristy has a great voice, better than Brooke's actually but Brooke has a unique kind of style and that is why she is still in I guess. Personally, I did not like Carly's rendition either; she shouted a lot and the back up singers seemed to drown her out. Also, I say this with some hesitation as I dont want to offend anyone but I think the whole tattoo scene with her and her husband turned off lots of people

Pickled Pink · 04-24-2008, 10:56 AM

I've wondered if the tattoos didn't put a lot of people off. I didn't like Carly's tattoo on her arm at all at first, but I kind of got used to it.

Face tattoos are seen by most people as scary and anti-social. Unless maybe if you live somewhere in the South Pacific.

I don't know how to love him would have been a much better choice for Carly!