Top Six Show season 7

Kira · 04-22-2008, 07:07 PM

Well guys, there were some surprises tonight! I thought Syesha, Carly and the two Davids were just great. I did not think Brooke or Jason had it tonight and I think probably Brooke will go home. David Cook was really spectacular and I agree that he can sing anything. What are some of your opinions?

rwealone · 04-22-2008, 07:31 PM

Alright!, musical theater is my bailiwick, so I feel qualified to contribute my 2 cents.
Of the 6 who performed, tonight, the only one I would not cast in a show is Castro. The most outstanding, who I would cast in a lead, is Syesha. It's obvious that she has experience in musical theater. The others, except for Castro, did a fair job of faking it. If cast in a show, they would need work.

nobelson · 04-22-2008, 07:43 PM

Carly was amazing tonight! I loved the Simon Loves Me This Week shirt LOL

Young_br · 04-22-2008, 08:36 PM

the show was different...the only thing that i have to say that i love Brooke very much and i hope she's safe.

KellieShellieGirl · 04-22-2008, 10:21 PM

As for tonight's show,the only stand out was David Cook and felt that David Archuleta was great,but not fantastic this week. Syesha was in her element,i could definately see her going into broadway and theater work. Brooke was good,but not great,as I feel she was emotionally connected to the song,she's possibly in danger this week,and Jason Castro took a risk,but just fell flat.I Think this is his week to be eliminated. Sorry to the Carly fans,but this girl just screams and shouts through her song choices.I'm not feeling it.

KellieandCarrieFan · 04-22-2008, 10:21 PM

I Honestly Wasn't That Into The Show Tonight. It Was Very Sad For Me To Watch Without My Girl. lol. But I Didn't think that Brooke was as bad as they said she was. I like her a lot and she's who got my votes since Kristy's gone. But This Year Has Been So Out There That just About Anything Can Happen. I Would Send Jason Home No Questions Asked. I Thoughht He was HORRIBLE!!! Brooke Was Still My Favoriate Of the Girls, Even With Her Mistake, But She'll Probably Be In The Bottom. God, I Want Syesha Gone SO Bad But I Guess She'll Stick Around Another Week. I Have No Idea Who Will Be In The Bottom With Brooke and Jason Though. I Guess It Will Come Down To Fan Bases. lol.

KellieandCarrieFan · 04-22-2008, 10:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by KellieShellieGirl

As for tonight's show,the only stand out was David Cook and felt that David Archuleta was great,but not fantastic this week. Syesha was in her element,i could definately see her going into broadway and theater work. Brooke was good,but not great,as I feel she was emotionally connected to the song,she's possibly in danger this week,and Jason Castro took a risk,but just fell flat.I Think this is his week to be eliminated. Sorry to the Carly fans,but this girl just screams and shouts through her song choices.I'm not feeling it.

I Agree About Carly. I Didn't Hate Her performance But She Was Screaming. She Could Be In Danger. I Think Jason Will Be Going Buh Bye This Week. But I Think Brooke, And Probably Be Carly Will Be Joining Him In The Bottom. God They Better Not Can Brooke This Week, I've Already Lost My Two Favoraites Back To Back. If They Can Brooke, That Would Mean It Would Be My Three Favoriates Back To Back. But We're At The 6th Place Curse Now So Anything Is Possible. I Don't Think ANYONE Is Safe. LOL

lionel2341 · 04-23-2008, 05:51 AM

I think Brooke will be safe, it's a real treat to see an artist make a mistake on live TV and come back with a good performance. I think there is too much over confidence in some Idols this year. I think Carly's performance was not my cup of Tea. I think only Syesha and Brooke stayed true to Andrew L. Webber's Music. Andrews comments during the one on one showed he held out real promise for Brooke and felt she understood what the song was all about. I really would have loved to hear Kristy's version of "Don't cry for me Argentina" it fits her voice. It could have been a highlight of the show. I was a little surprised that the guys sang female songs, Many of these Broadway shows have excellent male parts. I'd be interested in hearing Brooke's Studio recording, I'll bet it's full of passion.

Since Kristy didn't make it, all my votes go for Brooke. I would love to see this Young Women go far in this competition. She's just a great roll model for many young ladies.

Debra Byrd and Rickey both agreed that Kristy's performance this week would have been Awesome and put her in as a top contender.

Ernie

kelliedawnpicklerfan · 04-23-2008, 06:49 AM

Poor Brooke! JASON NEEDS TO GO!!!!!!!!!!!!

AshlaeSeacrest · 04-23-2008, 07:19 AM

Poor Brooke, I felt sorry for her last night. I hope she's safe tonight but I won't be surprise if she goes.

Kellielover101 · 04-23-2008, 08:34 AM

I Think Jason is going to go home but if Brooke goes home I hope she has the same successful Career as Kellie!!

AshlaeSeacrest · 04-23-2008, 09:06 AM

I say Syesha or Jason goes tonight. I don't think Brooke will go but she'll be in the bottom 2.

pick_pickler23 · 04-23-2008, 09:14 AM

I think Brooke and Jason did the worst last night and I'm scared because Jason is my favorite. lol I think Brooke has been going downhill the last few weeks and the "puppy dog" face she always gives the judges needs to stop. I hope she goes home tonight.