top 16 - Girls

Young_br · 03-05-2008, 07:20 PM

tonight was really good, i don't know what Simon is talking about

Kady just proved one more time that she's my biggest disappointment in all the 7 seasons of the show, not that she did bad but the others girls are so much better!
Brooke,Asia'h,Carly,Ramiele and Syesha... they all did good!
i'm pretty upset with the judges, they are seriously trying to hard pimping Kristy and i'm not the only one thinking that.

sorry Kristy fans.

north_clt · 03-05-2008, 07:30 PM

Who is Kristy?

Young_br · 03-05-2008, 08:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by north_clt

Who is Kristy?

this year country girl...

top 24

YouTube - Kristy Lee Cook - Rescue Me - Top 12 Girls

top 20

YouTube - Kristy Lee Cook - You're No Good - Top 10 Girls

KellieShellieGirl · 03-05-2008, 09:56 PM

If you don't know who Kristy Lee Cook is,your hiding under a rock. Kristy was fabulous tonight and the song was a great choice for her.The other stand outs of tonight's performances were Carly,Brooke,and Asia'h.

rwealone · 03-05-2008, 10:08 PM

They were good, for the most part.
IMO, the 1st one did pretty bad.
I hope the big rocker chick goes home. The one with the stupid blond streak in front of her hair. She didn't sing all that bad, I just don't like her.

robert1848 · 03-05-2008, 10:53 PM

IMO, two of these three will be leaving:

Amanda Overmyer (based on her first two performances)
Asia'h Epperson
Ramiele Malubay

(Did I get all the spellings correct? Man, these are tough names!!!)

I thought Brooke White was the best (Brooke amazes me every week, and I think she might have a shot at the finals with David, and seriously, has a shot a beating him). Syesha was a close second.

Kady Malloy, Kristy Lee Cook, and Carly Smithson all did well. I am not as impressed with Carly as the judges seem to be, but she does have talent.

Kristy really needs to find super songs....I love listening to her sing. I thought last night was her best performance, and if it weren't for a little loss of control at the end of the song, she would be right up there with Brooke. She seems to be still learning a bit....Brooke seems very confident and polished. If Kristy continues to improve, she will give Brooke a run for her money for the best female.

After this week's performance, my vote for the best guy or gal goes to Brooke. But it is close, very close, and if David A. pulls out any more songs like Imagine, Brooke is going to be in a tough fight.

The top 12 are going to be amazing.....and there may not be a weak singer among them. I have no doubt this will be the strongest season yet.

ADDENDUM: Top three guys: the three Davids.....no other guy is remotely close. Going home: Luke and Danny. David A. had a bit of an off night IMO, mostly due to the song, and the other two Davids made some headway into his lead.

Astropickledeggs · 03-05-2008, 11:38 PM

Kristy is my top girl this year, followed by Brooke. They both did really great Wednesday night. Kristy seems to still be dealing with the effects of that flu thing, I hope she kicks it quickly cause the girls have one less day to get ready for next week.

I also like Kady, but she just has'nt put anything together despite the talent being there. Hard to figure that one out, I think she's pretty much guaranteed to go home this week. Besides Kady, I think Syesha will be leaving. If not her, then Asia'h.

If I could pick the ones that I personally want to go home, they would be Amanda and the 'over-pimped' Ms. Smithson.

north_clt · 03-06-2008, 08:02 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by KellieShellieGirl

If you don't know who Kristy Lee Cook is,your hiding under a rock. Kristy was fabulous tonight and the song was a great choice for her.The other stand outs of tonight's performances were Carly,Brooke,and Asia'h.

I just haven't been watching the show.

Pickled Pink · 03-06-2008, 08:04 AM

I think Amanda and Kady will be leaving.

Kady's song was just plain depressing sounding. Not much life there.

Amanda sounds too limited.

I thought Brook stood out the most for me. As for Kristy, she sings well but I just can't seem to warm up to her. Also, she doesn't seem to have a consistent style.

KellieDawnFan · 03-06-2008, 08:48 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by rwealone

They were good, for the most part.
IMO, the 1st one did pretty bad.
I hope the big rocker chick goes home. The one with the stupid blond streak in front of her hair. She didn't sing all that bad, I just don't like her.

I kind of like her singing... went to you tube and she has lots of hits...they[judges] say she is a female Daughtry??

even if she goes home I am sure she will start recording and making albums

Kira · 03-06-2008, 09:41 AM

I did not agree with Simon at all that Amanda was the best; I do not think the girl can sing worth a hoot, she just screams louder and louder and I think she has no charisma. Carlie is a rocker style also but she sings far better than Amanda: no comparison, although I do think Carlie is overrated. I loved Brooke and Christie last night and also Carlie; I was disappointed with Ramiele and I think she might be in danger and also Kady might be going home. But with Simon's praise of Amanda, even though she should be going home I dont think she will.

rwealone · 03-06-2008, 09:49 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kira

I did not agree with Simon at all that Amanda was the best; I do not think the girl can sing worth a hoot, she just screams louder and louder and I think she has no charisma. Carlie is a rocker style also but she sings far better than Amanda: no comparison, although I do think Carlie is overrated. I loved Brooke and Christie last night and also Carlie; I was disappointed with Ramiele and I think she might be in danger and also Kady might be going home. But with Simon's praise of Amanda, even though she should be going home I dont think she will.

My problem with Amanda is her personality or should I say the lack of it.
Piers Morgan has more personality than her. ***yucks***