The Idols were great!

[lionel2341]

Here's an Excellent post from IDF


"I wonder how many people who complain about Haley's looks that have actually bought CD's by Britney Spears, Beyonce, Jessica Simpson etc. If she was not hot, would Britney have a music career? Britney has an average voice, her songs are written by professional songwriters and her songs are put together by professional producers. Beyond her looks, Britney Spears does not have a whole lot to offer. Looks are part of the package regarding pop stars. You don't see average to below average looking people with stellar voices topping the pop charts. That is just part of reality."


Unkie Ernie

[steve]

Originally Posted by Picklers#1Pickle

Hey, Chris Daughtry was bald and look at him now. I happen to be the #1PhilPhan!

That's my fault.I brought up the fact that he reminds me of Nosferatu. I'm just joking around. I like Phil. He's a good singer.

But he does remind me of Nosferatu.

[Countrygal919]

Originally Posted by lionel2341

Here's an Excellent post from IDF


"I wonder how many people who complain about Haley's looks that have actually bought CD's by Britney Spears, Beyonce, Jessica Simpson etc. If she was not hot, would Britney have a music career? Britney has an average voice, her songs are written by professional songwriters and her songs are put together by professional producers. Beyond her looks, Britney Spears does not have a whole lot to offer. Looks are part of the package regarding pop stars. You don't see average to below average looking people with stellar voices topping the pop charts. That is just part of reality."


Unkie Ernie

None of them got started on a talent show If Jess who is one of my favorite singers were on a talent show up against Lakisha, Jordin, Melinda, Chris D, or Jennifer Hudson. I'd be complaining about how far she made it too.

Thats the difference between AI and the rest of the music industry, tis supposed to give unconventional stars a chance to make it.

[lionel2341]

"None of them got started on a talent show If Jess who is one of my favorite singers were on a talent show up against Lakisha, Jordin, Melinda, Chris D, or Jennifer Hudson. I'd be complaining about how far she made it too.

Thats the difference between AI and the rest of the music industry, tis supposed to give unconventional stars a chance to make it."

I agree Heather.

Please understand that I like Haley's Style, that's why I'm a Fan of hers. I don't like Haley because she has "Great Legs." She was my favorite along with Baylie Brown from the start. If I had a choice it would have been Baylie, since she didn't make it, I threw my support to Haley and Jordan who are the real novice singers in this season. I don't think Haley will win, Never did, But I want to see her go as far as she can. As far as the Guys go, my vote goes for Blake, I think he has real talent.

Unkie Ernie

[Countrygal919]

I understand that you like Haley's voice but *glances at signature*. Some people don't care for her voice and only care for her legs. Theres an entire website out there dedicated to her legs, so I can't believe that everyone who likes her simply likes her style/voice. Just like everyone out there who likes Blake and or Chris doesn't like them for their style/voice.

At the end of the day its a talent competition, and I hope talent wins out over looks within the confines of the show, if looks carry people further outside of the show so be it, because they are no longer being judged for their talent, but their ability to fit into the mold their record label assigns them.

If Britney Spears and Paris Hilton can release albums with little to no talent, then anyone on AI should be able to as well. But looks shouldn't cause a person to win a talent competition.

[lionel2341]

Ok Heather I give up, It seems you don't like me, so no matter what I say about Haley, you knock me down. That's OK. And you couldn't even control yourself and had to zing my Signature.

I will no longer post on this Web Site Unless it concerns Kellie. You've Won