Idol losing a very important demographic - Page 4

Kellie_MINX · 03-20-2007, 01:32 PM

Alright, I'm going against the majority, but I love this season. I know I'm absolutely addicted to Idol and could never turn my back on it, but this season I've been more motivated to vote than ever before. I've voted every week so far, whereas in the past I've only voted a select few. Like Carrie in the finale.

Ah, anyways. I think this season has got something different from the past few. They're finally getting the focus back on pop music, instead of country and rock. After all, it is a pop singing competition. I know I say that all the time, but it's true.

I was disappointed about Antonella leaving, but I found the top 12 to be a great mix of people. That stage does definitely change people. I think everyone up there represents something unique.

Anyways, I just think American Idol is a great show and the contenders are extremely talented people up there for a reason.

fanofkellie · 03-20-2007, 04:01 PM

Who the heck keeps voting for Sanjaya? Sundance and Brandon getting voted off instead of him is ridiculous. Of course we can blame the three judges for choosing him for the final 24 in the first place. And Sabrina getting voted off instead of Haley is also incomprehensible. Sabrina's voice is so much better. Even the judges were shocked over that, noting that America really got it wrong.

I agree that this season is down from previous years, especially last year with Kellie. Kellie is so special and unique, I doubt there will ever be another AI season that will equal season 5.

My favorite this year is Melinda, although I won't be voting.