Who's Journey Ends Tonight?

[Pickled Pink]

I'm sure the little teary eyed scene with Ryan when Haley was talking about how she was so moved when Simon finally said something nice to her will keep Haley in it. Plus, she looked great and did well with her song.

She's got people's attention now. For sure she's safe for this time.

[stupidl0vesong]

Originally Posted by Pickled Pink

Also, I think Haley is starting to catch on with some people.

I agree. She got my attention last night.

I think Brandon will get sent home.

I give up on Sanjaya. At this rate he'll be in the finale with Melinda.

[WildPonies85]

Originally Posted by KellieKitty

I thought that Haley was good last night! She had a beautiful tone to her voice, and she looked like a star, too! I think that Brandon or Stephanie might go. Should be Sanjaya, but he is in 3rd place on dialidol.

Yuck! I can't stand Sanjaya, if he stays on another week, I'll be blocking my ears the next time he butchers another song! I sure hope he doesn't stay around for country week, I don't want to see him butcher a perfectly good country song!

[KellieandCarrieFan]

Brandon or Stephanie I think is sent ''home''.

Oh I hope so. They're the two I I don't like.

I hope its not Haley. She's my new favoriate this season since Alaina was sent home. I actually broke my own rule and voted for her last night. I wasn't gonna vote because no one was blowing me away but I wasn't ready to see her go so I did vote for her. I thought she was fantastic. And I agree with Simon. She looked like a Star.

[#1_Pickler_Fan]

Originally Posted by KellieandCarrieFan

Oh I hope so. They're the two I I don't like.

I hope its not Haley. She's my new favoriate this season since Alaina was sent home. I actually broke my own rule and voted for her last night. I wasn't gonna vote because no one was blowing me away but I wasn't ready to see her go so I did vote for her. I thought she was fantastic. And I agree with Simon. She looked like a Star.

Me too...Haley is my new favorite since Alaina went home as well. I voted for Haley because I don't think she needs to leave just yet.

[WildPonies85]

Article from Detroit News recapping last night's episode:

Jones doesn't let down Motown

Adam Graham / The Detroit News

Phil McCarten / Associated Press

Hopeful LaKisha Jones gave the strongest performance Tuesday.

'American Idol'

8 p.m. Tuesdays, 9 p.m. Wednesdays on Fox, Channel 2

Recapping Tuesday's episode of "American Idol":

The Good: Flint's LaKisha Jones -- note, she now likes going by "Kiki" -- gave the strongest performance of the evening as the contestants tackled Diana Ross' songbook. Jones was the one contestant who veered off the path, singing Billie Holiday's "God Bless the Child," which she got away with because Ross sang it in "Lady Sings the Blues." (Slick, Kiki. Slick.) Also on their game were Melinda Doolittle (singing "Home") and Chris Sligh, whose Coldplay-y "Endless Love" took a beating from judges but stood as the best male vocal of the night.

The Bad: Sanjaya Malakar's hideous "Ain't No Mountain High Enough" prompted Simon Cowell to say Ross was "gonna freak" when she heard it. Brandon Rogers, Gina Glocksen and Haley Scarnato also dropped the ball, but lucky for them, Malakar's still in the competition.

The Closet: Ryan Seacrest and Cowell are always teasing each other about their sexuality, but Tuesday's exchange was perhaps their most awkward yet: After Doolittle complained about her high heels, Seacrest asked Cowell what advice he had regarding high heels. "You should know, Ryan," Cowell said, to which Seacrest replied, "Stay out of my closet!" "Come out!" Cowell said, referring to Seacrest's "closet." Is this show still rated TV-PG?

Who Should Go Home: If he doesn't get voted off by viewers, producers should kick Malakar off for butchering a Motown classic.

What's next: Diana Ross sings, and someone goes home on tonight's episode.

http://www.detnews.com/apps/pbcs.dll...40433/1032/ENT

[CalamariKellie]

If I could pick, I'd say that these people should go home (in this order...):

1. SANJAYA M.
2. Haley S.
3. Brandon R.

[kellierox02]

I really want, Lakisha, Jordan, Blake, Chris (the one w/ the big hair), and Gina to stay
GINA IS MY FAVEORITE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[kellierox02]

Haylie is comming around. Shes not so bad, you know I hope she stays in because I want to see more that she can do. I personally think she is a goodsinger, and shes pretty.....

[CalamariKellie]

I'm not saying Haley is bad...I just don't think she belongs to be there with Jordin, LaKisha, Stephanie, Melinda, and BLAKE (In no particular order...)

[KellieShellieGirl]

With the way things are going this season,we might see a real shocker tonight with Chris Sligh in the bottom 3,along with Brandon Rogers,and Sanjaya,with Sanjaya in the top leaving Brandon and Chris in the bottom 2 and Chris getting eliminated.It's happened before,so this is just a prediciton. We will just have to wait and see.

[KellieShellieGirl]

Originally Posted by kellierox02

I really want, Lakisha, Jordan, Blake, Chris (the one w/ the big hair), and Gina to stay
GINA IS MY FAVEORITE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Gina is one of my favorites Sammy,the rocker chick has to stay.

[WildPonies85]

Originally Posted by KellieShellieGirl

Gina is one of my favorites Sammy,the rocker chick has to stay.

I agree! I say enough of the guy rockers, let's see some girl rockers do well!

[Jess]

I am hoping its Sanjaya but I have a feeling it might be Stephanie