Rumors about the winner's single - Page 2

AshlaeSeacrest · 05-19-2006, 07:48 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hil

See I personally think the song is actually not written for the TWO that will be in the finale, but Taylored for the person they want to win. JMO

That's why I said they thought it was going to Taylor/Chris finale with Chris winning. The song is probably more suit for a males voice and possibly written for Chris. Now that Chris didn't make the finale. I have a feeling that the song will fit Taylor more than Kat because it's suit for a males voice.

Pickled Pink · 05-19-2006, 01:44 PM

This is very interesting. Hopefully, the song will have some wiggle room so it can be arranged a little less rocky for both Taylor and Katharine.

If it is rock and if it can't be changed much, it will benefit Taylor the most.

kellie4idol5 · 05-19-2006, 01:57 PM

i cant wait! but if it is true i wish kellie could sing it! i miss her voice!

babolo · 05-19-2006, 04:08 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by AshlaeSeacrest

Now I know these is a weird parings but remember season 1 Tamyra was the chosen one (like Chris) but got the boot in the final 4 (like Chris). Kelly was really never a chosen one (Like Taylor). Everyone thought Tamyra would win with Kelly as a runner up (like when people thought Chris would win, Taylor a runner up). AI never plan for Justin to make the final 2 (Like Katharine) because they thought the final 2 was lock deal for sure and it wasn't. Plus Justin and Kat also have another thing in common (besides AI didn't think they would make the finale in their seasons) they are also NOT from the south.
Now do you guys understand it more now?

I don't understand at all.

Kellie ROX15 · 05-19-2006, 04:14 PM

Go Kat!!!!

babolo · 05-19-2006, 04:14 PM

Kelly (Clarkson) should write the winners single with Tamyra and Nick. They are all great writers.

SoonToBeCelebrity · 05-21-2006, 09:20 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by AshlaeSeacrest

OK I think I know what's going on. NOW let's go back to Season 1 and the winners single. REMEMBER AI said they keep 1 or 2 contestants in mind when picking a finale song. ALSO they pick this song WEEKS before the final 2 is announced!

Season 1- The winners single was for a Kelly/Tamyra finale instead Justin made the finals. They didn't think he was going to make it all the way. Which the songs suit Kelly more cause it was most likely written for a female's voice.
Season 2- Clay and Ruben both had different songs that suit their styles. They both sang well. Imagine if Kimberley Locke had made the finale. The songs were written for male's voice.
Season 3- Fantasia and Diana sang ''I Believe''. before the final 2 was announced, EVERYONE thought it would be a Fantasia/Latoya finale (I thought so too) so it suit Fan more than Diana. But Diana probably knew it was pick for Fantasia but she tired to do the best she could with the song.
Season 4- Carrie and Bo sang ''Inside Your Heaven''. They knew it was going be Bo/Carrie finale. To me I think they already knew Carrie would win so I think IYH was pick for her.
Season 5- Who did EVERYONE think would make the finals? Chris & Taylor. This winner single is probably more suited for a males voice. I really don't think they thought or even plan for Katharine to be in the finale. So there you go. That why I seriously think the winner single was really to suppose to fit Chris/Taylor finale probably more written for Chris cause AI thought he would win was lock deal. This season much more like Season 1 if you think about it.

Tamyra=Chris
Justin=Katharine
Kelly=Taylor

Now I know these is a weird parings but remember season 1 Tamyra was the chosen one (like Chris) but got the boot in the final 4 (like Chris). Kelly was really never a chosen one (Like Taylor). Everyone thought Tamyra would win with Kelly as a runner up (like when people thought Chris would win, Taylor a runner up). AI never plan for Justin to make the final 2 (Like Katharine) because they thought the final 2 was lock deal for sure and it wasn't. Plus Justin and Kat also have another thing in common (besides AI didn't think they would make the finale in their seasons) they are also NOT from the south.

Now do you guys understand it more now?

No...

SoonToBeCelebrity · 05-21-2006, 09:22 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by AshlaeSeacrest

That's why I said they thought it was going to Taylor/Chris finale with Chris winning. The song is probably more suit for a males voice and possibly written for Chris. Now that Chris didn't make the finale. I have a feeling that the song will fit Taylor more than Kat because it's suit for a males voice.

So are you saying that Taylor will win b/c the finale song was written to suit a males voice?

Because that makes no sense.

Oh and how you say that I Believe was sung better by Fantasia, I dont think thats true, Fantasia killed the song. Thr first time I heard Diana sing it, I was in tears, she did it beautifully. She even had Kelly Clarkson in tears.

So dont doubt that Katharine wont be able to sing the finale song, because anything is possible..when you believe.

KelliePicklers1Fan · 05-21-2006, 09:58 AM

I'm excited to see that!

kellie4idol5 · 05-21-2006, 01:56 PM

im going to be obssesed with this song..i know it!

Huston · 05-22-2006, 07:22 PM

I do think they should have an up-tempo single for the winner for once...