Mandisa?!

[Gerald]

wow, she did not deserve to go!

[sdnil427]

i agree. but i was only voting for kellie, so i shouldn't be talking

[texdale]

It takes the entire package to win AI that is after Idol-2

[underwoodfan23]

I agree! i voted for Mandisa and I'm very sad to see her go! But, and i feel really bad saying this, better her than Katharine or Kellie!

But, seriously, Mandisa will be missed!!

[Magicman32]

Originally Posted by texdale

It takes the entire package to win AI that is after Idol-2

Exactly

[werss]

She did not deserve to go, but she had two bad weeks in a row and America voted.

[AshlaeSeacrest]

The song just didn't fit her. Mandisa is still a great singer and she's always will be the best female in the competition. NO ONE can beat her she just pick lousy songs to sing. She will be missed and if I had my way she would be in the Top 6. KELLIE FANS: We have seen what happen to Mandisa so now can't give up on voting for Kellie. We can't assume she is safe!!

[Moodygal]

Well, looks like I was almost right putting Mandisa and Elliott in the bottom three but I thought Elliott would go. It was only a mather of time before Mandisa had to go anyway,but she is a great singer. I really only care for Kellie, and a little for Ace & Chris in this competition.

[KelliePicklers1Fan]

I agree, I was in shock that Bucky nor Ace were in the bottom three. And since she from TN, so many people are sad about that.

[wb1]

Originally Posted by AshlaeSeacrest

The song just didn't fit her. Mandisa is still a great singer and she's always will be the best female in the competition. NO ONE can beat her she just pick lousy songs to sing. She will be missed and if I had my way she would be in the Top 6. KELLIE FANS: We have seen what happen to Mandisa so now can't give up on voting for Kellie. We can't assume she is safe!!

It's funny that because one of the "judges" said that she was the best female in the competition, so many people just take that as fact. Kind of reminds me of when Paula told Anwar that he had "technically the best voice in the competition," when 99% of the America knew that it was Carrie who did. Anwar couldn't sing anything if it was less than a scream, but some people hear that and run with it. Anwar has technically the best voice, yeah, right. If you believed that I have a bridge in New York that I want to sell you. To me it was a joke. The same goes for Mandisa. Sure, she could sing, but so can many others. There was no way on earth that America was going to vote her into anything close to a win. It was just a matter of time and her time came up. It's the same with Bucky. Although he was the best this past Tuesday, he'll never win. He's a little too goofy with the walk back and forth across the stage and then pointing his knees outward. He'd be better off just standing still because then he wouldn't seem so awkward to me.

Now the competition is going to get more intense. Without Mandisa, some of her votes are going to go to someone else. Some won't care anymore, some will vote for Paris, and some will most likely go to Katharine. I don't see many of them going to Kellie though. They'll see her as the front runner and probably vote against her. That'll start happening more and more as the eliminations proceed. Don't be surprised if you see her in the bottom three in a few weeks.

[Pickled Pink]

A person on this thread said: Now the competition is going to get more intense. Without Mandisa, some of her votes are going to go to someone else. Some won't care anymore, some will vote for Paris, and some will most likely go to Katharine. I don't see many of them going to Kellie though. (snip) Don't be surprised if you see her in the bottom three in a few weeks.
__________________
I Love Carrie & Katharine!

Personally, I love Kellie Pickler and this is why I am here. To support her. If you don't care for Kellie Pickler no one is forcing you to stay on this forum.

[kellie4idol5]

yeah i was shocked but i didnt want elliott to go! i <3 him

[AshlaeSeacrest]

Originally Posted by Pickled Pink

A person on this thread said: Now the competition is going to get more intense. Without Mandisa, some of her votes are going to go to someone else. Some won't care anymore, some will vote for Paris, and some will most likely go to Katharine. I don't see many of them going to Kellie though. (snip) Don't be surprised if you see her in the bottom three in a few weeks.
__________________
I Love Carrie & Katharine!

Personally, I love Kellie Pickler and this is why I am here. To support her. If you don't care for Kellie Pickler no one is forcing you to stay on this forum.

I agree Nikki!!! I honestly don't believe that Mandisa's fans will vote for anyone. I have seen A LOT of her fans though that said they are voting for Taylor, Kellie, and Paris if Mandisa doesn't make it. I guess it depends on who they like.

[Magicman32]

Originally Posted by wb1

Now the competition is going to get more intense. Without Mandisa, some of her votes are going to go to someone else. Some won't care anymore, some will vote for Paris, and some will most likely go to Katharine. I don't see many of them going to Kellie though. They'll see her as the front runner and probably vote against her. That'll start happening more and more as the eliminations proceed. Don't be surprised if you see her in the bottom three in a few weeks.

Kellie will benefit more from Bucky's impending exit a lot more than Paris will from Mandisa's.

I don't know who switches to Kat, it won't be Kellie fans cause our girl will be moving on when Kat goes, so that's the only fanbase that could truly help her.

Kellie is a frontrunner, your right about that, but nobody can vote her out. Yeah sure, they can split votes with the others in hopes it costs Kellie, but the impact won't be enough.

[AshlaeSeacrest]

^ That's why you shouldn't split votes. It doesn't do anything or helps your favorites.