I voted for Simon. He can be quite blunt about what he thinks and sometimes he hits it right on the head.
But other times he can be completely wrong as he has HUGE blind spots. He doesn't know much of anything about fashion or about country music for example. He criticized a girl during the audition for singing Crazy calling it a weird song choice! I don't think he even recognized it!
The comment Simon made about how Lakisha looked in her beautiful green dress was just strange. But then, who would take fashion advice from a guy who wears a T-shirt week after week after week? LOL
But it's interesting that you put the viewers in as the judge. I think the viewers are very harsh judges too. And their choices are hard to understand at times. Sometimes if you don't have a very big fan base, it's one bad performance and you're out!
